Please note: some details of the check system (e.g. PIN-usage) described in these reports have been improved and simplified since publication.
FOUR PAWS International
FOUR PAWS International
#TracingTheTrade
The illegal puppy trade is rife with animal cruelty and deception. Every year, countless puppies are bred in deplorable conditions, taken from their mothers too early and transported across Europe to be sold online via classified ad sites. To help combat this exploitative trade, FOUR PAWS has developed a 'Model Solution for full traceability across the EU online puppy trade', which requires all puppies to be microchipped and registered, and the seller’s details verified, before they can be advertised online.
Statements of Support
Stakeholders across the EU have already aired their interest in participating in a pioneer project to implement the Model Solution, including EuroPetNet, pet registries and classified ad sites.
FOUR PAWS is in touch with and supported by several further stakeholders.
“After exploratory talks, the Board of Europetnet wishes to express its support for the aims and approach of the FOUR PAWS Model Solution. We believe that cooperation between online advertisement platforms and Identification and Registration Databases through the integration of their respective processes will not only ensure tighter regulation of the online trade in dogs, but will also enable traceability of those involved and ultimately go a long way to eradicate the illegal puppy trade.”
Michel Schoffeniels, President of Europetnet, Belgium
“Eurogroup for Animals is the only pan-European umbrella organisation for animal welfare. We channel the national influence of each of our 66 members into a powerful voice, creating opportunities for a change across Europe that cannot be achieved individually. Our aim is to improve animal welfare as quickly as possible by working together with the EU institutions to deliver better legislation and enforcement. Eurogroup for Animals has contributed to FOUR PAWS’ Model Solution Report, and will encourage the implementation of the outlined ideas by bringing such effective and efficient solutions to policy makers and key stakeholders at the EU level.”
Reineke Hameleers, Director of Eurogroup for Animals, Belgium
“Animal welfare and the quality of our advertisements in the animal market have been the highest priority for us for years: we have already introduced a number of measures, some pointing the way, and we are not tired of pushing ahead vigorously with the fight against the illegal puppy trade. The logical consequence can therefore only be to follow FOUR PAWS‘ idea of complete traceability in the online puppy trade and to actively participate in shaping it. Together, with our alliance partner VDH, the Verband für das Deutsche Hundewesen, we will therefore implement the Model Solution and thus form a strong alliance: as a market leader in serious online pet transfers and as part of a national media group, we also see the obligation to promote this topic socio-politically, and to establish the Model Solution of FOUR PAWS as a perspective standard, and to persuade the politicians to support us consistently in our efforts against illegal activities.”
Daniel D'Amico, Chief executive at deine-tierwelt.de, Germany
“The Animal Welfare Officers of the Federal States support the Model Solution presented by FOUR PAWS as an important step for traceability in the EU-wide online trade of pets. Not only the lack of identification and registration obligations in Germany and the associated lack of traceability of pets, but also the anonymity of sellers prevalent on the internet on classified ad portals, allows billions of dollars of criminal activity at the expense of countless animals.The solution presented by FOUR PAWS shows a feasible way to tackle the complex problems of the illegal puppy trade and to get to grips with ethically unacceptable animal welfare practices through targeted cooperation between the involved parties."
Diana Plange, elected spokeswoman for the Animal Welfare Officer of the Federal States and State Animal Protection Officer of Berlin, Germany
“The FOUR PAWS Model Solution is an effective means of halting criminal activities in the pet trade and thus preventing tremendous animal suffering by ensuring full traceability and transparency of the trade. The implementation of the Model Solution following the enactment of the Animal Health Law (Regulation (EU) 2016/429 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 9 March 2019) would lay a new foundation in animal health law. It is likely that non-EU countries will follow suit. TIR welcomes the model, which would also be an important step for Switzerland, as the current structures are still far from effective in stopping the illegal trade. TIR therefore fully supports the Model Solution and considers it essential that the various institutions, some of which have been newly created, work together.“
Bianca Körner, Lawyer at Stiftung für das Tier im Recht (TIR), Switzerland
“Providing a quality classified ad site by ensuring maximum security for our users is one of the priorities of anibis.ch. For years, we have been convinced that simply deleting the category 'animals' is not a solution and that is the reason why we are conducting discussions with animal welfare associations in order to put in place effective measures to curb the illegal puppy trade. Since 2016, the microchip number must be provided to anibis.ch, in order to publish an advertisement for a dog, and since March 2018 that has also been the case for purebred cats. We manually check each microchip number on Europetnet.org. In Switzerland, the new Animal Protection Ordinance, which came into force on 01.03.2018, requires that the seller's full name and full address have to be published in the classified ad. Unfortunately, these efforts are in vain because it is impossible for us to verify if the information indicated is correct. With the introduction of automatic checks of the correctness of the data - in order to advertise dogs - we would be able to further complicate the illegal trade of puppies. Anibis.ch supports the FOUR PAWS’ proposal and is gladly offering its help as a test platform.”
Jelena Moncilli, Anti-Fraud Specialist at anibis.ch, Switzerland
“Dyreværnet ('Animal care') in Denmark support the Model Solution and all the work being done to implement 'tracing the trade' in regard to online sales and import/export of puppies, and dogs in general. We will work to facilitate the implementation of the Model Solution in Denmark via Dansk Hunderegister (the Danish Dog Registry), Fødevarestyrelsen (the Food administration, from where animal welfare is governed) and relevant politicians.”
Dr. Rikke Lee, CEO Dyreværnet, Denmark
“The dubious trade of puppies, increasingly being sold via classified ad sites, represents a serious animal welfare problem in Europe and is associated with immense animal suffering. In order to dry-up the illegal market and create much needed transparency, the bmt expressly supports the Model Solution presented by VIER PFOTEN. Since it ties in with existing European law and can fall back on already existing modern database systems for the identification and registration of animals, its successful implementation and national roll-out is ultimately only a question of political will.”
Karsten Plücker, Chairman of Bund gegen Missbrauch der Tiere (bmt), Germany
“ANIMALDATA.COM welcomes the FOUR PAWS initiative against the illegal puppy trade which requires all breeders and pet traders to be registered. In order to be able to trace each animal, a breeders or traders registration number would need to be recorded in both state and I&R databases prior to any transfer of a puppy. ANIMALDATA.COM is ready to implement the related requirements of EUROPETNET in Austria.”
Dr. Herbert Mueller, Internationale Tierkennzeichendatenbank animaldata.com, Austria
“The anonymous online pet trade must be banned in order to protect animals from abuse and torture. The FOUR PAWS Model Solution demonstrates how the online puppy trade can be regulated and how the legal online trade can implement binding rules that protect animals. Implementation of the Model Solution could enable complete Europe-wide traceability and transparency of the sale and purchase of animals, ultimately serving both animal welfare and human welfare.”
Stefan Weber, Tierschutzbeauftragte der Länder, SPD Schleswig-Holstein, Germany
“The edogs website, which specialises in the online trade in dogs, is proud to announce its collaboration with FOUR PAWS. The online platform, which has been in operation since December 1st 2017, has a key focus on providing safety in the online dog market. During a time of illegal puppy traders, and so-called ‘trunk puppies’, it is important for edogs to be able to offer a trustworthy platform. FOUR PAWS is committed to establishing full traceability in the online puppy trade, so the edogs team sat down with them to develop this collaboration. Through the FOUR PAWS Model Solution, edogs has learned how it is possible to stop the illegal puppy trade. The team from edogs is happy to support this project to make the dog trade safer.”
Liselotte Laffree, edogs.de, Germany
“The Veterinary Association for Animal Protection e.V. (TVT) has been concerned about the lack of transparency in the international puppy trade for many years. Over 1,300 of our members who work as veterinarians in practices across Germany, as official veterinarians and in business and research, are increasingly confronted with the consequences of this trade; an increase in transmissible diseases such as distemper and parvovirus, seriously ill puppies are being sold online with no way of tracing their origin, and many overwhelmed owners are having to give up their behaviorally disturbed imported dogs. The Model Solution proposed by FOUR PAWS will provide transparency and traceability of this trade at European level, and improve both animal welfare as well as human and animal health.”
Dr. Andreas Franzky, Chairman of Tierärztlichen Vereinigung für Tierschutz e.V. (TVT), Germany
“Clear identification and registration of dogs in member clubs has been a standard within our association for a long time. The VDH participates intensively in both the alliance "Arbeitsgemeinschaft Welpenhandel" and network 'K&R' (Identification and Registration) in order to achieve a national registration of all dogs and a registration in Germany. Within the EU member states, Germany is one of the three countries in which there is no national obligation to register. In order to establish effective rules to control and restrict puppy trade within the EU, it is particularlyimportant to control and restrict online animal trade. The FOUR PAWS Model Solution and the inclusion of an EU-wide registration of all breeders, sellers and facilities such as animal shelters provides a concrete way of achieving these goals.”
Udo Kopernik, Verband für das Deutsche Hundewesen, Germany
“The puppy trade is a serious animal welfare problem. Because it is so easy for profiteers to escape control when selling via the online trade, they use this option extensively. It is therefore important to create legal requirements, especially for these online platforms. Sellers and the animals they advertise must be registered to ensure traceability.”
Susanne Mittag, SPD member of the Bundestag, Germany
“Verbraucherschutz.de is committed to the interests of consumers and tries to protect them from harm. In my opinion, this also includes warning consumers against buying animals, especially dogs and puppies, on the Internet, since these are mostly sick puppies that come with high veterinary costs that are incurred by consumers. We therefore welcome the new EU law, which obliges commercial sellers to provide a registration number. Verbraucherschutz.de supports the Model Solution from FOUR PAWS and demands that all dogs should also be registered. In this way, online portals can understand the origin of the dogs and the identity of the dealers. In order to make trading really secure, all online platforms must comply with these measures.”
Gunda Lauckenmann, verbraucherschutz.de, Germany
“I comprehensively support FOUR PAWS’ campaign against the illegal online animal trade and I am pleased about the dedication of all animal welfare activists on this issue. The illegal trade has been ignored for far too long and the suffering of tens of thousands of animals has been tolerated. This must end once and for all. We need mandatory identification and registration of all dealers and full, transparent traceability of the animals - as suggested by the future-oriented Model Solution from FOUR PAWS.”
Andreas Hartenfels, spokesman for animal welfare, parliamentary group BÜNDNIS 90 / DIE GRÜNEN Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany
“Illegal puppy and pet trade through internet platforms and digital sales exchanges leads to increased animal suffering and increased risks to animal and human health. Therefore, it should be prevented in the future. In addition, a mandatory nationwide digital registration of pets is required, for example using microchips in a clever database, to keep the pet trade as transparent as possible.”
Joschka Knuth, animal welfare policy spokesman for the parliamentary group BÜNDNIS 90 / DIE GRÜNEN Schleswig-Holstein, Germany
“The Model Solution from FOUR PAWS starts exactly where we can legally put an end to the illegal puppy trade: by tackling the lack of traceability in the online trade. If online classified advertising platforms could be equipped with tools that make it possible to verify the identity of the seller and check the registration of the puppies - market access for illegal trade could be effectively blocked. Nevertheless, we also have to make the consumer responsible. Everyone who buys a dog is responsible for ensuring that this is done in a serious manner. Spontaneous bargain purchases from dubious sellers on the Internet keep this criminal million-dollar business going and causing a lot of animal suffering.”
Christoph Skutella, animal welfare policy spokesman for the FDP parliamentary group Bavaria, Germany
“Animal Society has long been concerned with the illegal trade in companion animals, which is still an ongoing phenomenon in Romania, despite the fact that important legal steps have been taken in order to combat it. Therefore, Animal Society welcomes the comprehensive and efficient Model Solution presented by FOUR PAWS and is ready to contribute to its implementation at the national and European level. We believe the Model Solution will prove crucial in limiting and eventually eliminating the enormous animal suffering caused by this reprehensible trade.”
Anca Tomescu, President of Animal Society, Romania
Latest News & History of this project
June 2020
A report by international experts to the European Commission included a suggestion to validate a companion animal’s registration to a traceable seller in a pet registry in order to advertise the animal online. Calls for Europe-wide identification and registration of companion animals, and their international traceability were also included. Find out more here. The report is based on the Croatian Presidency of the Council of the European Union and Eurogroup for Animals’ expert workshop, “The Illegal Pet Trade: Game Over” of 21 April 2020.
February 2020
Milestone action by MEPs to end the illegal puppy trade!
The European Parliament has requested action from the European Commission to tackle the illegal trade in companion animals. With the implementation of mandatory registration for all dogs and cats, huge progress can be made towards protecting animals, the EU’s internal market, and consumer rights from the negative implications of the cruel trade. Read the FOUR PAWS press release here. Source: www.europarl.europa.eu
January 2020:
Ireland releases new ANIMAL HEALTH AND WELFARE (SALE OR SUPPLY OF PET ANIMALS) REGULATIONS 2019: Persons selling five or more animals per year must register themselves and their premises with the government. All dog advertisements must display the dog’s microchip number, the dog’s origin, and if applicable, the seller’s registration number.
6th November:
FOUR PAWS presents :'PetSAFE‘ - a system for EU online classified ad sites that checks whether puppies advertised for sale online are registered, at the Expert Conference: 'Time to Act - A Mandatory Identification and Registration (I&R) for dogs and cats in Germany and Developments in the EU', Berlin. Link to the presentations. Link to PetSAFE presentation video (from minute 31), and to all presentation videos made at the conference.
16th October:
FOUR PAWS UK submitted written evidence to the UK parliament’s Puppy Smuggling Inquiry and made various suggestions to help control the online puppy trade
8th October:
Europetnet’s Finbarr Heslin presented 'PetSAFE' at the event 'The Next Political Term: What's on the Horizon for Animals' in Brussels
June 2019:
Presentation of the Model Solution to the Europetnet General Assembly
Identification and Registration in the EU
External references to the Model Solution
- International Companion Animal Management Coalition mentioned the Model Solution as a Case Study in their “HUMANE DOG POPULATION MANAGEMENT GUIDANCE“ Report
- Tracing the Trade: Model Solution for Full Traceability across the EU Online Puppy Trade. Article from International Companion Animal Management Coalition
